Guidance for reviewers
  • Rating Scale:
1 = lowest (e.g., reject)
5 = average (e.g., accept with major modifications)
10 = highest (e.g., accept without revisions or with minor revisions)
  • Please rate the paper and its presentation in the categories listed below.
  • If you encounter any problems with the on-line review submission process (questions, confusion, etc.), please contact the administrator via e-mail at:
  • Please complete ALL the entries. Thank You!

Review Evaluation Form
Your Name:
Your Email:

For AuthId enabled: ( :zap emailfrom="":)

Your Name:

( :zap reviewername="":) ( :zap revieweremail="":) ( :ifend:)

Paper Number:Paper Title:
Version Reviewed:
Topic for AIEDAM:Style and Organization:
Technical Quality:Research Evaluation:
Overall Consideration:Consider it as:
Your Confidence in Your Evaluation:
Comments to the Editor (will not be seen by the Author(s)):
Comments to the Author(s): Quality of Writing, Figures & References:
Number of AIEDAM Papers Cited:
Comments to the Author(s): Extra References to AIEDAM Papers:
Comments to the Author(s): Technical Review:

(Please check that you have entered ALL the information above)

Thank you very much for completing the AIEDAM Review Form!